business
AMNews|unlim|stf|top|illlus|468x325|

Photo illustration by Jennifer Wenger / amednews

Managing office stress with laughter

You don't have to be a stand-up comedian to incorporate humor into your practice. And it can put everyone -- physicians, staff and patients -- at ease.

By Bob Cook — Posted June 28, 2010

Print  |   Email  |   Respond  |   Reprints  |   Like Facebook  |   Share Twitter  |   Tweet Linkedin

We're not trying to pull your leg -- using laughter as a technique to improve office morale, productivity and patient relations is no joke.

Two decades of peer-reviewed research on the benefits of laughter and humor in the workplace bear out the conclusion that there are positive effects of injecting levity into the day.

In the office, laughter can foment increased creativity, productivity and teamwork, even if not every comic remark draws a giggle. Merely an attempt at humor, even if unsuccessful, can carry the same benefits. Laughter helps people feel more in control of their situations, even if those situations seem out of control. Laughing with patients can get them to open up about their conditions, establish yourself as a good listener, and reduce the risk of getting sued.

Don't laugh. Actually, you're probably not laughing. Doug Farrago, MD, a family physician in Auburn, Maine, who runs a humor magazine and blog called Placebo Journal, measures the level of laughter in doctors' offices as: "Not much."

Insurance hassles, declining pay, more patients, staff conflicts, everyday tragedies experienced by patients -- no wonder there is a dearth of mirth. But experts say all those problems make it more essential for leaders in a physician office to make people smile.

"People are more likely to be satisfied with their job, less likely to burn out, which is a particular problem in the medical profession," said Chris Robert, PhD, a University of Missouri business professor who researches humor in the workplace.

"In a medical context, interactions between workers, but also between patients and caregivers, is likely to be better when people are in a better mood," Robert said. "It's not to say you always want to be cracking jokes. But well-timed humor can spill over into other aspects of people's relationships and their attitudes toward their job. Humor has an important function of forming relationships in society. It turns out we really like the sounds of other people's laughter."

Added Dr. Farrago: "If you can't smile during the day, man, you're done."

Laughter in the office

Pulitzer Prize-winning humorist Dave Barry, challenged by his editor at the Miami Herald to define a sense of humor, came up with this: "A sense of humor is a measurement of the extent to which we realize that we are trapped in a world almost totally devoid of reason. Laughter is how we express the anxiety we feel at this knowledge."

However, even the staunchest advocates of humor in the workplace understand why laughter often is not the desired means to express the anxieties of the physician office.

Humor gone wrong can have bad consequences. Look at the terms for failing at comedy: Laughter can be a minefield. In the wrong hands and used the wrong way, humor can bomb. Jokes that die can result in sexual harassment or discrimination lawsuits.

Before getting to what kind of humor kills (even terms for succeeding in comedy are severe) in the office, experts want to take the comedic pressure off.

Getting staff to laugh isn't just about telling jokes. It's about creating an environment in which people are comfortable enough to share and chuckle, with laughter rolling out of natural patterns of communication.

"Frankly, I think it's very difficult for an organization to go from zero to 60 in terms of humor," Robert said. "You can't go from a serious environment where humor is frowned upon to a fun-loving organization where humor happens all the time. Interventions to introduce humor are not going to be successful."

A doctor doesn't have to "enact Jerry Seinfeld-esque behavior," said Melissa Wanzer, EdD, a communications professor at Canisius College in New York who has researched humor and laughter in the medical and nonmedical workplace.

You can find people online who will come to your office, clown nose and all, to teach your office how to lighten up. But experts say there is one thing any physician can do, very easily, for free, to make the office a little funnier, and send a signal that it's OK to laugh: self-deprecation.

"Talk about your receding hairline, your gut, your tie," Dr. Farrago said. A physician who laughs at himself or herself about innocuous things can loosen up a tight environment.

Wanzer said there are many ways to defuse the everyday tension -- staff sharing funny stories about their kids, giving humorous asides, telling dumb jokes.

"Why did the cyclops quit teaching? He had only pupil," Wanzer said. "People like that. It's silly. It doesn't offend anyone. Except cyclops."

Spending time together outside work helps build a comfort level that encourages humor, but shared work experiences can help develop material to blow off steam with a few laughs. The material doesn't need to be in the form of traditional jokes; in one nonmedical office, Wanzer saw humor and bonding grow out of staff taking turns dressing up a stuffed bear.

The one absolute no-no, on the other hand, is humor directed at others' expense, including making fun of patients with fellow staff members. "Humor that targets others based on race, religion, political affiliation, sexuality -- all of those things, that's risky," Wanzer said. "There is a very good chance that humor is going to be perceived as inappropriate."

Peer-reviewed research shows that although laughter can help people open up, an office where jokes are made to be mean, to point out divisions or to make underlings laugh at whatever the boss says, has the opposite effect. People shut down or are less creative and more stressed.

However, experts say the fear of humor that bombs is no reason to deny the sound of laughter to everyone. "I'm a little less concerned about people using inappropriate humor and it being an unmitigated disaster," Robert said. "But even when people attempt to use humor that others don't find very funny, I think, socially, that someone attempting to use humor and attempting to lighten the mood has benefits in and of itself."

Laughing with patients

Even many practices where laughter abounds among the staff would never dream of joking in front of patients. Ken Jeong, MD, now a comedy star on TV (NBC's "Community") and in movies (memorable turns as a naked guy leaping out of a car in "The Hangover" and a cranky ob-gyn in "Knocked Up"), has said in various interviews that he kept the humor out of his interactions with patients while he worked as an internist.

However, experts say a well-timed joke or remark can be a great tool when dealing with patients, making them more at ease and relaxed.

Experts often use Southwest Airlines as an example of an organization that successfully made humor a part of its culture.

Southwest eases the minds of its passengers who are nervous fliers and opens the ears of passengers who normally would ignore pre-flight safety announcements, making for a more productive encounter. A typical safety announcement joke: "Should the cabin lose pressure, oxygen masks will drop from the overhead area. Please place the bag over your own mouth and nose before assisting children or adults acting like children."

In the same vein, a physician can use humor to ease the mind of a nervous patient, or open the ears of a patient who is not fully engaged, making for a more productive encounter.

"I think in health care, where there is such anxiety and [patients] are unhappy to be there, even small doses of humor are appreciated," Wanzer said.

Even better, she said, is when the staff and physicians appreciate the patient's humor -- it tells the patient that he or she is being listened to. "If a patient initiates humor, it's great if the staff laughs," she said.

Kelly Haskard-Zolnierek, PhD, an assistant professor of psychology at Texas State University, has helped develop something called the "Patient-Physician Humor Rating Scale."

The spreadsheet-style statistical analysis of patient-physician interaction is about as funny as dry toast.

But the analysis, based on hearing tapes of patient-physician interactions, provide evidence that light humor and banter between doctors and patients is positive, she said.

It's not that patients wanted to roll down the aisles after an office visit. The use of humor was a sign that the physician was "being warm, being friendly and things of that nature," Haskard-Zolnierek said.

Various studies note that well-timed, light humor with patients can make life less stressful for physicians and staff -- especially if it makes patients open up about what's bothering them and place more trust in their physicians.

Like with staff, humor that is mean, racist, sexist, homophobic, overly sarcastic or inappropriate turns off patients. Also, if patients joke in that way to doctors and staff, it only adds stress, and experts say physicians should feel free to tell a patient that sort of humor doesn't play in that room.

But seriously, folks. Laughter in the office, with staff and patients, isn't about making sure everyone has a smile at all times. It's about using a positive, physical reaction to help release stress and improve morale, experts say. Nothing but laughter is as bad as nothing but a straight face.

After all, Dr. Farrago, the physician who makes a sideline of being funny, said: "You have to know when it's time to get serious."

Back to top


ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Do's and Don'ts of office humor

Humor and laughter have many documented physical and emotional benefits. But even if -- or especially if -- you consider yourself a funny person, experts have some advice on how to make sure office humor is beneficial and stops short of becoming a detriment to patients' or staff's well-being.

Do

  • Make jokes or comments at your own expense.
  • Tell corny, innocent jokes.
  • Share funny stories.
  • Feel free to laugh if a patient says something funny.
  • Allow staff to post light or whimsical cartoons in the office area.
  • Apologize to someone who was offended by a joke.
  • Allow the sound of laughter, to help break the tension of the day.
  • Know when it's time to take things seriously.

Don't

  • Make jokes or comments at your staff's or patients' expense.
  • Tell mean, racist, sexist, homophobic jokes.
  • Share funny stories -- if they're mean, racist, sexist or homophobic.
  • Pretend you didn't hear anything if a patient says something funny.
  • Allow staff to post cartoons indiscriminately around the office.
  • Ask people who were offended by a joke where they lost their sense of humor.
  • Ban the sound of laughter, for fear of some humor-related lawsuit or a loss of credibility with patients.
  • Turn your office into a full-time comedy club.

Back to top


Joking -- the right way

Humor can help in patient encounters if it is based on empathy and respect. Here are examples of constructive physician humor:

Example: An acutely ill patient sits in an exam room. A physician enters the room and asks, "How are you?" The patient reflexively responds, "Fine." The physician counters, "Not true," and the patient laughs.
Why it's constructive: The humor comes from the physician poking gentle fun at the patient's rote politeness, at odds with her illness. The joke also gives the patient permission to drop the "fine" façade and signals that the physician is even more aware than she is of her distress.

Example: During rounds, the physician enters a patient's room. The patient is finishing breakfast. "Good morning," the physician says. "Looks like you ate well. Why didn't you leave any for me?" The patient chuckles.
Why it's constructive: The physician acknowledges the discomfort a patient might feel during a private, uncomfortable, unusual moment. The joke humanizes the physician -- and the patient.

Example: During an office visit, the physician discusses an abnormal test result and suggests more evaluation. The anxious patient asks, "Doctor, should I be concerned?" The physician responds, "Well, we need to evaluate this symptom. I'll tell you when it's time to start worrying. It's not time yet." The patient chuckles.
Why it's constructive: The physician acknowledges the patient's anxiety, tries to soothe it, but doesn't diminish it. The talk of further evaluation communicates a commitment to ongoing involvement that says, "Whatever happens, I won't abandon you."

Source: "Humor in the physician-patient encounter," Archives of Internal Medicine, April 26, 2004 (link)

Back to top


ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISE HERE


Featured
Read story

Confronting bias against obese patients

Medical educators are starting to raise awareness about how weight-related stigma can impair patient-physician communication and the treatment of obesity. Read story


Read story

Goodbye

American Medical News is ceasing publication after 55 years of serving physicians by keeping them informed of their rapidly changing profession. Read story


Read story

Policing medical practice employees after work

Doctors can try to regulate staff actions outside the office, but they must watch what they try to stamp out and how they do it. Read story


Read story

Diabetes prevention: Set on a course for lifestyle change

The YMCA's evidence-based program is helping prediabetic patients eat right, get active and lose weight. Read story


Read story

Medicaid's muddled preventive care picture

The health system reform law promises no-cost coverage of a lengthy list of screenings and other prevention services, but some beneficiaries still might miss out. Read story


Read story

How to get tax breaks for your medical practice

Federal, state and local governments offer doctors incentives because practices are recognized as economic engines. But physicians must know how and where to find them. Read story


Read story

Advance pay ACOs: A down payment on Medicare's future

Accountable care organizations that pay doctors up-front bring practice improvements, but it's unclear yet if program actuaries will see a return on investment. Read story


Read story

Physician liability: Your team, your legal risk

When health care team members drop the ball, it's often doctors who end up in court. How can physicians improve such care and avoid risks? Read story